HORRIBLY GOOD ICE CREAM
FLAVORS
click me!
SUNDAES
click me!
SLURPS
click me!
TO-GO
click me!
Ice Cream Monster menu
Greetings, ice cream lovers. Dr. I.M. Twisted here, your official guide to the Ice Cream Monster menu. You are about to enter a world of wild flavors, crazy toppings, sundaes, and ice cream creations that taste as delicious as they look!
At Ice Cream Monster in Matawan, NJ, every flavor has the power to transform. Any ice cream flavor can be turned into soft serve, just like you have seen on TikTok and Instagram. Our viral soft serve swirls have reached over 10 million views on @icecreammonsternj, and now it is your turn to try the experiment in person.
Looking for the best ice cream in Matawan NJ, a fun ice cream shop near you, or a unique soft serve ice cream experience in New Jersey? You found the lab. Our menu is packed with over 30 ice cream flavors including vegan and sugar free, unique toppings, sundaes and shakes.
Our Build-a-Monster Sundaes are the best way to get creative. Choose your ice cream, pick your toppings, add your drizzle, and build a dessert that is completely yours. From gummy eyeballs and cookie pieces to sprinkles, candy, fudge, whipped cream, cherries, and monster toppings, every sundae can become its own delicious creation.
Not sure what to build? Do not worry. Our Mad Scientist Scoopers are here to help. They can guide you through our flavors, toppings, soft serve options, and monster combinations so you can create the perfect treat.
You can explore our menu below, but the best Ice Cream Monster experience is always in person. Visit our Matawan ice cream shop, bring your friends and family, and come see why Ice Cream Monster is one of the most fun ice cream places in New Jersey.
Start exploring the Ice Cream Monster menu below and get ready to build something delicious. One taste, and you can see the magic that Ice Cream Monster brings to life.
Birthday Cake vanilla ice cream with blue icing swirls, sprinkles and vanilla cake chunks
Butter Pecan butter pecan ice cream with pecan bits
Cereal Killer vanilla ice cream with grape nut cereal crunch
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough vanilla ice cream with chocolate chip chunks and edible cookie dough bites
Classic Chocolate classic chocolate ice cream
Coffee Fudge coffee ice cream with a fudge swirl
Cookie Creature blue ice cream, creme of an Oreo flavored, loaded with crushed Oreos, edible cookie dough bites and chocolate chip cookies
Cookies & Scream vanilla ice cream with crushed cookies & creme
Cotton Candy pink and blue ice cream, cotton candy flavored
Death by Chocolate chocolate ice cream with a fudge swirl, crushed cookies & creme, and chocolate chip chunks
Gruesome Graham graham cracker ice cream with graham cracker swirls and chocolate covered honey comb
Mango Sorbet refreshing mango sorbet
Mint Chocolate Chunk mint ice cream with chocolate chip chunks
Peanut Butter Oreo cookies & creme ice cream with peanut butter swirls
Pistachio pistachio ice cream with bits of pistachio nuts
Purple Haze black raspberry ice cream with oreos
Raspberry Sorbet refreshing raspberry sorbet
Salted Caramel Pretzel vanilla ice cream with a caramel swirl and chocolate covered pretzels.
Strawberry strawberry ice cream with real strawberry chunks
Strawberry Cheesecake cheesecake ice cream with a strawberry swirl and cheesecake chunks
Toasted Marshmallow S'mores marshmallow ice cream with graham cracker swirls and chocolate chip chunks
Vicious Vanilla award winning vanilla ice cream
VEGAN
All Sorbets
Vanilla
NO SUGAR ADDED
Butter Pecan
Vanilla
Some flavors listed may be out of stock, call or come in for the most updated stock.
Build a Monster Sundae Create your own delicious ice cream sundae! Post on social media for a chance to be chosen as Ice Cream Monster of the Month, and they receive a free hat and one free build a monster sundae!
Classic Sundae 2 scoops of ice cream, whipped cream, syrup, topping and a cherry
Apple Pie A La Mode A warm apple pie topped with a scoop of ice cream, caramel drizzle, whipped cream and a cherry
Banana Split 3 scoops of ice cream, banana, whipped cream, syrup, topping and a cherry
Blue Cookie Creature 2 scoops of ice cream topped with whipped cream, chocolate syrup, oreo eyes, cookie crisps and a cookie
P.B. Lover's 2 scoops of ice cream topped with crushed Reeses, peanut butter sauce, chocolate syrup, whipped cream and chocolate chips
S'mores 2 scoops of ice cream topped with a toasted marshmallow, graham crackers, Hershey's chocolate, chocolate syrup and whipped cream
COFFEE and ESPRESSO
Iced Coffee
Hot Coffee
Espresso
Killah Koffee Bags
FLOATS
Classic (canned soda)
Bizarre Bubblies (specialty craft soda)
Coffee
SHAKES
Regular
Extra Thick
Creature Cake Shakes: P.B. Lava Cake, Magical Unicorn, Beastly Brownie Batter, Blue Cookie Creature, Killah Coffee Marble Cake
Blue Cookie Creature
Killah Coffee Marble Cake
P.B. Lava Cake
Magical Unicone
Beastly Brownie Batter
These are only the toppings on top of the shake, any flavor can be chosen and the cup is drizzled with syrup. Serving size depicted in photo may not be equivalent to amount on shake.
REGULAR TOPPINGS
rainbow sprinkles crushed p.b. cups M&Ms chocolate sprinkles
crushed Oreos
sour gummy worms
chocolate crunchies
nerds
gummies
cereal marshmallows
crushed peanuts
crushed butterfinger
crushed heath bar
wet walnuts
cherries
strawberries
syrups: chocolate, caramel, hot fudge, marshmallow, raspberry, Nutella, vanilla
crushed pineapple
MONSTER MODIFICATIONS
oreo eyes
unicone horn
gummy body parts
gummy eyeball
jelly horns
edible cookie dough brownie bites banana horns
toasted marshmallow
CONES
6-pack Oreo Ice Cream Sandwiches
6-pack Chocolate Wafer Ice Cream Sandwiches
Monster Size Ice Cream Sandwich
Ice Cream Pie